|
By Mary Ellen Shepard, PhD
You have cancer
were the worst three words that Arthur Foster 65 had
ever heard. Foster of Harbor Springs Michigan
was diagnosed with lung cancer in January 2000 and underwent the
removal of two lobes of his right lung and three ribs. But the cancer
came back in September 2000. With a prognosis of three to six months
to live Foster says I didnt want to lie
in bed and die. I wanted to find a clinical trial.
Clinical trials provide the proof that a new treatment is better
than the one being offered. They can offer a source of hope for
cancer patients who have nowhere else to turn or those seeking potentially
more beneficial or less toxic therapies. While most doctors offer
the option of a clinical trial to patients some do not. Finding
a clinical trial can be a difficult task.
Resources for Clinical
Trials
Cancer care can be found within driving distance for most Americans.
Many oncology practices are involved in clinical trials which
might be based in one region but enroll patients in that trial from
across the country through local oncology practices. In other words
a clinical trial sponsored by the National Cancer Institute (NCI)
in Washington D.C. could enroll patients from across
the country if their local cancer treatment center chooses to take
part. National organizations that sponsor or conduct clinical trials
across the country include federal agencies cooperative groups
cancer centers and the pharmaceutical industry.
Travel is often a limiting factor for cancer patients who
may choose to stay close to the support of family and friends. For
this reason a search for a clinical trial should always begin
at home with your own oncologist who should not only be able
to tell you if something is available locally but also give
you resources to see what may be available in other parts of the
country.
The NCI and the American Cancer Society (ACS 800-ACS-2345
or www.cancer.org) can put a
patient in touch with local centers conducting trials. Consider
contacting cancer centers within your state or city
suggests Clinical Trials Specialist Andrea Denicoff RN
at the NCI in Bethesda Maryland.
Depending on the type of cancer and where you live you may
have many options some of which might involve travel. Local
wellness centers can also offer assistance. Eileen Coan MA
MLS medical librarian at The Gathering Place (216-595-9546;
coan@touchedbycancer.org)
in Beachwood Ohio is happy to assist anyone in
finding a clinical trial.
The earlier a drug is in the clinical trial process the fewer
places it is available. This means those facing recurrent disease
and who are not responding to the prescribed regimen might find
only a few institutions where a new approach to their disease is
in clinical trial.
Clinical trials have so many requirements they almost
require the patient to live far away for long periods of time. The
inconvenience is extremely difficult and it is difficult to
weigh the benefits for therapeutics that are unproven
says Eric Rowinsky MD Director of Clinical Research
at the Institute for Drug Development Professor of Medicine
in Oncology The University of Texas Health Science Center
San Antonio Texas. However some patients are willing
to travel.
I enrolled in a trial and drove about 1000 miles every
three weeks to participate Foster explains. Foster enrolled
in a trial at The Arthur G. James Cancer Hospital in Columbus
Ohio which was testing the use of the drug suramin in combination
with Taxol® (paclitaxel) and Paraplatin® (carboplatin) in
nonsmall-cell lung cancer.
Most of the government-sponsored cancer clinical trials are conducted
through the NCI. A patient considering a cancer clinical trial
can start by contacting the NCIs Cancer Information Service
(CIS) at 800-4-CANCER or through the NCIs website www.cancer.gov
states Denicoff. There are 41 NCI-designated comprehensive cancer
centers throughout the United States. A list including contact
information is available at www.nci.nih.gov/cancercenters
or by calling the CIS.
The NCIs Physicians Data Query (PDQ) is one of the most
comprehensive databases of cancer trials available on the internet
at www.cancer.gov/search/clinical_trials.
This website provides access to more than 1800 open trials.
Also CIS representatives will do a customized search of the
PDQ based on an individual patients needs.
The internet is the best source of clinical trials information
says medical librarian Coan. Many websites contain databases of
active clinical trials. No single resource however lists
every cancer trial and those sponsored directly by pharmaceutical
companies are not listed in voluntary databases.
Contacting the pharmaceutical companies directly is often the best
source of information on trials they may be conducting. Also
check individual cancer center websites for industry-sponsored trials.
Common Ground
Other cancer patients are often a valuable source of information.
Contact local support groups through your hospital physician
or ACS. Cancer centers and cancer websites often have chat rooms
or email lists where patients can contact each other. Patients who
are already enrolled in a trial are often willing to discuss their
experiences with others.
However Dr. Rowinsky cautions Patients often make
recommendations based on their disease and experiences which
may represent misinformation to a patient who is making a decision.
Before You Begin
Fully understand both the risks and benefits of each trial you are
considering. Each trial has its own eligibility criteria and often
has restrictions based on the type and stage of cancer age
previous treatments received and current health status. Discuss
them with your doctor and/or contact the study coordinators conducting
the studies you are considering. It is helpful to determine whether
the trial is phase I II or III since each one has its
advantages and disadvantages.
Dont be afraid to ask questions. I made lists of questions
and took a tape recorder with me to my visits suggests
Barbara Sharpe 56 who enrolled in trial HMC 1197 within
the Blood and Marrow Transplant Program at the Ireland Cancer Center
of University Hospitals in Cleveland Ohio after being
diagnosed with stage IV breast cancer three years ago. She received
a blood stem cell transplant.
I was terrified the first day I had chemotherapy but
it didnt hurt. Two to three days later though
I was really sick from the side effects. I was not a great candidate
for chemotherapy; I got sick a lot and really tired. The newer meds
for nausea helped a lot she recalls.
Some patients tolerate treatments well however. I never
got sick. I did sleep a lot but I never missed a day of work
except to get treatments Foster says. Foster would typically
drive to Columbus on a Thursday have blood work drawn on Friday
receive treatments on Monday drive home on Tuesday and
be back at work on Wednesday. I still get numbness in my fingers
and toes but my hair is back and I feel great he says.
Cost can be another consideration. A patient is often responsible
for travel lodging or medical expenses not covered by
insurance. Recently a law was passed that requires Medicare to cover
routine costs associated with a clinical trial. Even if you dont
have medical insurance help may be available. Sharpe had no
assets or medical insurance when she enrolled in the trial. The
social workers in the Department of Human Services were wonderful.
They managed my case and Medicaid covered the expenses
Sharpe recalls. Information on financial assistance is provided
by CIS at cis.nci.nih.gov/fact/8_3.htm.
While clinical trials do not guarantee a benefit above standard
therapy sometimes patients do benefit from the treatments.
Patients who have participated in clinical trials often feel
they receive top-notch care whether they are in the standard therapy
or experimental treatment arm. The physicians tend to be leaders
in their field and have a dedicated research team says
Denicoff.
Foster agrees The doctors and nurses dont come
any better. They treated me like I was their dad and they
didnt want to see me die. Foster also gratefully acknowledges
I would not be here today if I had not participated in a clinical
trial. I would tell anybody in the world to go do it."
|